• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Home Garden Companion

Home Garden Companion

Ilona's Garden Journal

  • Plant Library On The Journal
    • All Season Garden Color
    • Sitemap
  • Garden chores
    • Essential Garden Tools For Beginners
    • Garden Tips and Advice
  • Ilona’s Garden Home
    • Old House Blog
    • Garden Librarian
  • Ilona’s Garden Flavor Shop
  • Privacy Policy

The Gardening Bubble

05.02.09 | Ilona Erwin | 8 Comments


You’ve heard of the real estate bubble, and talk of other bubbles as well, but we gardeners have our own forms of the dreaded “bubble”. Remember history’s “Tulipomania”? Yep, everyone had to have tulips, the latest and rarest one, and a bubble was born to illustrate all other bubbles. Wherever the tale of tulips are told, the story of tulipomania is trotted out: the beautiful tulip is showcased in Europe, the rich took notice and got involved (any patterns here ? eh?), and craziness ensued. Then, it all fell down. Humpty Dumpty was sitting on a garden wall in those times, I’m sure.

Anyway, I notice that people talk about the ups and downs of gardening popularity. They usually have jobs that involve some form of the landscape industry, so I understand their concern… While for the rest of us, we don’t get interested until it starts shutting down some of our favorite publications or diminishing our plant choices – or hitting our pocketbooks with a particularly cruel and unusual punishment. So I thought of noting something I found in my internet meanderings.

Back in the year 2000 or so was the article, “Modernism spells trouble in the Garden of Eden” , where they say this little gem of garden wisdom:

“Gardeners are a conservative lot,” says one[garden editor]. “You can’t pretend to them that gardening is like interior decoration, a matter of instant results.”

So true, that.

The article points to the instant garden “makeover” mentality of garden TV at that time as the contributing fault. It occurred to me that we had digested that thinking and made it our own over the past decade or so. It may have just been that this particular magazine, New Eden, was a little ahead of its time (or perhaps marketed poorly?). Whatever the cause at the time, I think we (culturally and collectively speaking) grew a whole crop of gardeners that loved instantaneous results.

Easy Gardening gardeners, with dreams of “no maintenance” yards -“younger, trendier”. This, then is the “gardening bubble”. The gardeners described as “Real gardeners” ™, are these: “The experienced gardener sees through them by the way they hold a spade and the language they use”. I would concur.

The conclusion was:”The key question has been whether the new instant-result gardening has a market, or whether it will be the traditionalists who triumph. So far, the traditionalists have it.”

In the short term that was wrong. I think the concerns of those who worry that gardening is losing its appeal to the masses and lost sales of gardening literature are due to the fact that the “new trendier” type of gardening temporarily won out, in spite of the fact that gardeners are conservative. The larger size plants at greater costs were ubiquitous, Yards were regularly “made over” at whim, a new wardrobe for your home that mirrored the glossy pages, all the while assuring us that it was as easy as pie. And it was… for a season. But because gardening is very much a set of skills acquired over a long time (a lifetime I might say), the longterm result is that the prophetic declaration that traditionalists will triumph now rings with a bit of truth.

Garden magazine publishers were hearing the death knoll even then,”The competition is not about to get any easier.” “Do not ask for whom the bell tolls…”

So where do gardeners go from here? I think because we are going into a tight economic situation that might well demand lifestyle changes, we are going to want things that hone and improve our skills and make economic sense. Everyone loves “organic” but do they know the fine tuned balance that produces good food and “sustainability”? As a culture we jump on bandwagons, but our times demand something with more substance and rooted more deeply into the ground of our nation and tradition. And in this is the Gardener, someone for all seasons.

I’m glad to be in your number.

Garden businesses that cater to the “Real gardeners” ™, and gardeners who propagate real love and learning for the craft will create something sustainable that contributes to the future generation.

I think this is the direction we should go.

Tags: garden trends,

Share this:

  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related

← Previous Post
Home and Garden Show Discount
Next Post →
My Garden Roots

About Ilona Erwin

I was a garden blog pioneer, and began writing on this blog in 2003. Before that I had begun a garden website that has been at its own domain since 2006, Ilona's Garden.

I still love writing, gardening, and art after all these years, although travel and grandchildren have become a big part of my life, now.

DISCLOSURE: I may be an affiliate for products that I recommend. If you purchase those items through my links I will earn a commission. You will not pay more when buying a product through my link. Thank you, in advance for your support! Privacy Policy

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Rob (ourfrenchgarden) says

    February 5, 2009 at 9:50 pm

    Hi Ilona

    I enjoyed reading this post. How true.

    The gardener with dirt under his/her fingernails will prevail.

    Sales of veg. seeds have been higher than those of flower seeds since 2006 or so in the UK. Perhaps the ornamental kitchen garden is the new trend in these times. Productive and good looking.

    Rob

  2. tina says

    February 6, 2009 at 12:04 am

    I think this has to be my favorite post of yours ever. All so well said. Gardening has its ups and downs, makeovers, do overs, and instant satisfaction for sure. The true lovers of gardening are probably the traditionalists and I think gardening will persevere. Thankfully!

  3. Teresa R says

    February 6, 2009 at 6:47 pm

    I agree! True gardeners are life-long gardeners who and should help educate others as to the benefits of gardening for both ourselves and the planet.

  4. TC says

    February 6, 2009 at 7:04 pm

    Well said. This could be related: I read where one of the bigger flower shows out west is going under after a 20 year run. Might this be the result of the “instant garden ‘makeover’ mentality,” extended out over a period of a couple decades?

  5. EAL says

    February 7, 2009 at 6:01 am

    Interesting post! This is exactly the kind of thing I have been thinking about. I am still not sure what the real trends are.

  6. Helen @ Gardening With Confidence says

    February 8, 2009 at 11:10 pm

    You’re garden mission statement is up at Gardening With Confidence – check it out http://tinyurl.com/cu9kdx and Thanks! Helen

  7. The Organic Gardener says

    February 11, 2009 at 11:07 pm

    Wow, that was an AMAZING article. If there was an inspiring button on the top of the page for rating, that is what I would pick. You are a very good analyst, a trade that I admire. I know a lot of people who are starting to do more organic gardening and less pesticides, herbicides, and fungicides. Like my self I believe in sustainably and not in the power of people wanting to control my life. You are an inspiration. and I look forward to reading more!

    ~Zach

  8. Ilona says

    February 13, 2009 at 9:39 pm

    You win! I will trade the love for an inspiring button 🙂 I appreciate the comments so much (all opinions are welcome here for discussion)

Primary Sidebar

Oh, hi there!

I was a garden blog pioneer, and began writing on this blog in 2003. Before that I had begun a garden website that has been at its own domain since 2006, Ilona's Garden.

I still love writing, gardening, and art after all these years, although travel and grandchildren have become a big part of my life, now.

Newest Postings Here

  • Hawaiian Flower Arrangements
  • HELLLOOOO, From The Other Side
  • February Gardening, Last of Winter in the Flower Garden
  • Compilation of Past Mini-Posts of 2003
  • Wayback in Ilona Garden Time

Visit for a Spell

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Mission

Finding your way home via the garden path

Books, Tools, Tips

Read reviews from the GardenLibarian

Portrait of a Gardener

gardener musings
Musings

What’s Wrong With Today’s Gardening?

Modern gardening
What Is Wrong?

Garden Journal

fine garden journal
Journal, Planner and Log Book
buy quality plants

You might also like

seeds

National Seed Swap Day in January

Garden advice

What Makes a Low Maintenance Garden?

Create A Child’s Garden, Grow Love For Nature

Growing Indoor Flowers In December

I Found Out About “She Sheds” And Coincidentally, About Friends

Newest Postings Here

  • Hawaiian Flower Arrangements
  • HELLLOOOO, From The Other Side
  • February Gardening, Last of Winter in the Flower Garden
  • Compilation of Past Mini-Posts of 2003
  • Wayback in Ilona Garden Time

Books, Tools, Tips

Read reviews from the GardenLibarian

Standouts

10 Useful Gardening Tips For Spring

Do You Grow Herbs? 10 Reasons To Love Them

10 Cool Season Annual Flowers To Plant

Standouts

August Gardening: Ten Suggestions

What are your ten top choices for perennial plantings?

ilonagarden

With village lights With village lights
Christmas decor #christmasspirit🎄 Christmas decor #christmasspirit🎄
Instagram post 17935013548845771 Instagram post 17935013548845771
Instagram post 17981374354427684 Instagram post 17981374354427684
Instagram post 17865517706595888 Instagram post 17865517706595888
Gift of flowers by my bedside Gift of flowers by my bedside
#mockorange #juneflowers #ohio #mockorange #juneflowers #ohio
Instagram post 18224713828022497 Instagram post 18224713828022497
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Join Me

  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2023 · Your Site Name

Hazel Theme by Code + Coconut