• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Home Garden Companion

Home Garden Companion

Ilona's Garden Journal

  • Plant Library On The Journal
    • All Season Garden Color
    • Sitemap
  • Garden chores
    • Essential Garden Tools For Beginners
    • Garden Tips and Advice
  • Ilona’s Garden Home
    • Old House Blog
    • Garden Librarian
  • Ilona’s Garden Flavor Shop
  • Privacy Policy

Can Gardening and Politics Co-Exist?

18.11.08 | Ilona Erwin | 4 Comments


In the fellowship of gardeners, that is. I have this tendency to compartmentalize, and so I have operated under the impression that gardening, like music, is something of a great unifier. But I am not so sure.

In certain parts of my world, others are a bit more conservative than I am, in other parts there is a narrow spectrum of differences in which, … the locale, and even wider differences among family members, do not find politics of particularly marked importance in the relationship. So it is something unusual to find that in the company of garden enthusiasts, and especially the garden bloggers, I am in the preserve of liberal leaning politics. Sometimes I wondered whether it impacted my blog, but then dismissed that idea with the knowledge that my sporadic unreliable blogging and networking probably had more to do with that. Yet, I still have a nagging curiosity. What determines more of a relationship? The passion for a garden or for politics? It could be that those of conservative views are more quiet about them in the garden community… or maybe not so many are gardeners? Maybe more of them are interior decorators?

This curiosity predates the present political climate which has played powerfully into our cultural emotions. Race, religion, war, macro-economics any one of which would mold our opinions; but I had imagined the garden to have been a sanctum which ushered us into a neutral ground of interaction.

That now seems naive. In some of my garden reading I realized how much of our garden ideas are inflected with our political mindset. We are not particularly partisan at all times, but we are quite impassioned on some issues.

I wonder if anyone ever did a demographic study?

Just some random thoughts….

Share this:

  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related

← Previous Post
Wonder About Winter 2008-9?
Next Post →
Bear With Me

About Ilona Erwin

I was a garden blog pioneer, and began writing on this blog in 2003. Before that I had begun a garden website that has been at its own domain since 2006, Ilona's Garden.

I still love writing, gardening, and art after all these years, although travel and grandchildren have become a big part of my life, now.

DISCLOSURE: I may be an affiliate for products that I recommend. If you purchase those items through my links I will earn a commission. You will not pay more when buying a product through my link. Thank you, in advance for your support! Privacy Policy

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Craig at Ellis Hollow says

    November 19, 2008 at 12:48 am

    Oh, don’t get me started Ilona …

    Gardens are usually an expression of our most positive values. And deep down inside, most gardeners — regardless of party affiliation — share many deep-seated (-seeded?) values. Appreciation for life and beauty. Satisfaction when hard work is rewarded. Sharing the bounty with those who aren’t so blessed. etc. etc.

    It’s just when we start trying to express our values through our sometimes perverted political processes (the ones that divide us and accentuate our differences) that things can get tense. I know more than a few folks who I admire and get along with on a gardening level but would have a hard time having a civil conversation with on politics.

    Maybe we can use gardening to help us work together to get through these tough times.

  2. tina says

    November 19, 2008 at 1:52 pm

    Gardening and politics can co exist. I am wondering what you find to be the political leanings in the garden blog community? I know that after the election there were so many positive posts, is that what you are talking about? No negative ones. That tells me the Republicans thought it better to be silent on the matter. I try to keep my political views out of it all, as you just never know how the other person will react to you. Such is life.

  3. Ilona says

    November 19, 2008 at 5:33 pm

    Craig- I love how your mind works (“deep-seated (-seeded?)”). You expressed my hope exactly when submitting that perhaps we can have our gardens as the platform for peaceful relations.

    Tina… you know Republicans are anything but quiet- you have only to read a few conservative political blogs to have that come in loud and clear. I read mostly the reasoned and logic oriented ones -on either side (life is too short for crazy rants), but the way you word this underlines what I perceive: most garden blogs that are politically inflected are to the left of center. I come to your attitude, as well. For the most part. My caveat here is the type of political influence that I noted while reading Oudolf+ Kingsbury ‘Planting Design: Gardens in Time and Space’. I took many notes to write some future posts ( maybe in early 2009)

  4. tina says

    November 19, 2008 at 6:41 pm

    Yes, Ilona, Garden bloggers are probably to the left. I know I am.

    Craig, You have it exactly correct, “gardens are usually an expression of our most positive values.” Hence our blogs too?

Primary Sidebar

Oh, hi there!

I was a garden blog pioneer, and began writing on this blog in 2003. Before that I had begun a garden website that has been at its own domain since 2006, Ilona's Garden.

I still love writing, gardening, and art after all these years, although travel and grandchildren have become a big part of my life, now.

Newest Postings Here

  • Hawaiian Flower Arrangements
  • HELLLOOOO, From The Other Side
  • February Gardening, Last of Winter in the Flower Garden
  • Compilation of Past Mini-Posts of 2003
  • Wayback in Ilona Garden Time

Visit for a Spell

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Mission

Finding your way home via the garden path

Books, Tools, Tips

Read reviews from the GardenLibarian

Portrait of a Gardener

gardener musings
Musings

What’s Wrong With Today’s Gardening?

Modern gardening
What Is Wrong?

Garden Journal

fine garden journal
Journal, Planner and Log Book
buy quality plants

You might also like

seeds

National Seed Swap Day in January

Garden advice

What Makes a Low Maintenance Garden?

Create A Child’s Garden, Grow Love For Nature

Growing Indoor Flowers In December

I Found Out About “She Sheds” And Coincidentally, About Friends

Newest Postings Here

  • Hawaiian Flower Arrangements
  • HELLLOOOO, From The Other Side
  • February Gardening, Last of Winter in the Flower Garden
  • Compilation of Past Mini-Posts of 2003
  • Wayback in Ilona Garden Time

Books, Tools, Tips

Read reviews from the GardenLibarian

Standouts

10 Useful Gardening Tips For Spring

Do You Grow Herbs? 10 Reasons To Love Them

10 Cool Season Annual Flowers To Plant

Standouts

August Gardening: Ten Suggestions

What are your ten top choices for perennial plantings?

ilonagarden

With village lights With village lights
Christmas decor #christmasspirit🎄 Christmas decor #christmasspirit🎄
Instagram post 17935013548845771 Instagram post 17935013548845771
Instagram post 17981374354427684 Instagram post 17981374354427684
Instagram post 17865517706595888 Instagram post 17865517706595888
Gift of flowers by my bedside Gift of flowers by my bedside
#mockorange #juneflowers #ohio #mockorange #juneflowers #ohio
Instagram post 18224713828022497 Instagram post 18224713828022497
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Join Me

  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2023 · Your Site Name

Hazel Theme by Code + Coconut